The South African Fleet Review, Africa's oldest navy parades its newest frigates

This article originally appeared in We gratefully thank Mr. Cusack for his permission to republish his article in Ahoy.

Fleet reviews are not very common occurrences. According to legend, the first fleet review took place when King Henry VIII on a whim gave the order to assemble his navy's ships as he wanted "to see the fleet together". On that occasion, the omnivorous monarch was rowed from vessel to vessel and enjoyed a repast on each. The tradition of the monarch reviewing the fleet continued, and usually took place to commemorate the coronation, to welcome a visiting monarch, or to commemorate some other event or occasion of great import.

Since the time of George III, British fleet reviews have typically taken place at Spithead between Portsmouth and the Isle of Wight. The 1814 review celebrating the Treaty of Paris was the last to be composed of only sailing ships, and included fifteen ships of the line and thirty-one frigates: "the tremendous naval armaments which has swept from the ocean the fleets of France and Spain and secured to Britain the domain of the sea". The 1937 Coronation Fleet Review was made famous by the BBC radio commentary given by Lieutenant-Commander Thomas Woodrooffe. The retired naval officer had met up with a number of chums from his more sea-worthy days in a pub before the broadcast. Woodrooffe's commentary was so incoherent that he was taken off the air within a couple of minutes; as the fleet was specially illuminated in the evening, Lt.-Cdr. Woodrooffe continually repeated "the Fleet's lit up"; "lit up" also being a euphemism at the time for being drunk.

As he reviewed the fleet, little did the (recently-resigned) Mr. Thabo Mbeki
know that he had less than three more weeks as State President.


Over the past three years, the South African Navy has commissioned four state-of-the-art Valour-class frigates and three Type 209 submarines, and to celebrate their entering into official service it was decided to have a Presidential Fleet Review.

The Presidential Fleet Review took place in Simon's Bay north of Simon's Town (Simonstad), the home base of the South African Navy.

The Valour-class frigates are part of the MEKO family of warships developed by the German shipbuilding firm Blohm + Voss. MEKO is short for Mehrzweck-Kombination or "multi-purpose combination", a shipbuilding concept based on modularity which aims at reducing costs and increasing long-term adaptability. The Valour-class frigates are classed by Blohm + Voss as MEKO A-200SAN, and make extensive use of "X-form" stealth structural design in which right angles and vertical surfaces are avoided. The ships have a radar signature of vessels half their size as well as 75% less infrared signature (in part due to their exhaust exiting below the waterline).


The last fleet review in South Africa was held in 1997, when President Mandela reviewed the fleet in commemoration of the 75th anniversary of the South African Navy.

The frigates - two of which were built in Kiel, the other two in Hamburg - have a top speed of 27 knots and a range of 8,000 nautical miles (at 16 knots), with an endurance away from port of 28 days. Their air capabilities include a flight deck that can handle 2 Westland Super Lynx helicopters, or 1 Super Lynx plus 2 unmanned aerial vehicles (typically used in reconnaissance), or 1 Atlas Oryx utility helicopter (for search & rescue, or transporting up to 20 troops), or 1 Rooivalk attack helicopter. The Oryx and the Rooivalk are products of South Africa's domestic defense industry, developed by necessity when the United Nations imposed an arms embargo on the country from 1977 to 1994, during which only Israel cooperated with South Africa in military research, exchange, and trade. The surface-to-air missile systems on the vessel were also developed domestically. (The surface-to-surface missiles, meanwhile, are the French-designed Exocets made famous during the Falklands War).

President Mbeki arrived in Simon's Town by helicopter, and proceeded to board the SAS Protea from which the Commander-in-Chief reviewed the fleet.

As the lead ship approached the Protea, a contingent of three helicopters from the South African Air Force took part. A Rooivalk led the way carrying the national flag, followed by an Oryx (adapted for Arctic rescue) carrying the Defense Force flag, with a second Oryx carrying the South African naval ensign. While most navies that trace their lineage to the Royal Navy bear the red Cross of St George, the South African Navy have borne a green cross instead since 1952 because the Afrikaner-dominated government of the time lacked an appreciation for those of the country's traditions that were of English origin. Perhaps this green cross should be called the Cross of St. Nicholas, given the Hollandic peoples' affection for that holy saint.

Three of the four frigates are named after battles from South African history, but the lead ship in the review, SAS Mendi (above), is named after the 1917 Mendi incident, in which a troopship full of black South African labourers sank, leaving 616 South African and 30 British crew dead. The black men were members of the 5th Battalion South African Native Labour Corps recruited to work in support of the Allied forces in France during the First World War.

En route from the shipbuilders in Germany to Simon's Town in South Africa, the SAS Mendi (Captain: Jimmy Schutte) met with HMS Nottingham at the site of the SS Mendi's sinking and laid wreaths in commemoration of the dead.

Next was the SAS Amatola (Captain: Guy Jamieson), named after the series of battles between the Xhosa tribe and Great Britain that took place in the Amatola mountain range along the Eastern Cape. In 2007, Amatola became the first South African frigate to participate in Basic Operational Sea Training (BOST) with the Royal Navy since South Africa became a republic in 1961.

Following Amatola was the SAS Spioenkop, seen above with its dour-faced Captain C.G. Manig. Spioenkop takes its name from the Battle of Spion Kop (as it is usually rendered in English; the ship's name is in Afrikaans), the great Boer victory over the British. Winston Churchill covered the Battle of Spion Kop as a war correspondent, and Mohandas Gandhi was a stretcher-bearer.

The final frigate in the review was the SAS Isandlwana (not pictured), named after the famous victory of the Zulus in the Anglo-Zulu wars. Isandlwana's first commander, Capt. Karl Wiesner, recently handed the vessel over to Capt. B.K. "Bravo" Mhlana, the first black South African to command a frigate. Capt. Mhlana received part of his officer training from the Royal Navy.

After Isandlwana came the offshore patrol vessels SAS Galeshewe and SAS Isaac Dyobha, followed by two minehunters, SAS Umzimkulu and SAS Umkomaas, and an inshore patrol vessel, SAS Tobie. Then came two of South Africa's three Type 209 submarines, SAS Charlotte Maxeke and SAS Queen Mojdajdi I. The fleet replenishment ship SAS Drakensberg finished up the review.

After the Presidential Fleet Review, Mr. Mbeki awarded medals and promotions back on land in Simon's Town (above) before heading back to Pretoria by helicopter (below).

The purchase of the four specially-built frigates included an option to buy a fifth and some politicians have even suggested building a sixth. But the purchase of four has sparked a controversy over whether South Africa really needed four brand new frigates when some of its more useful Israeli-built patrol vessels are nearing the end of their lifelines. The post-apartheid government has proved surprisingly willing, in a time of high unemployment and great economic uncertainty, to invest the country's resources in maintaining a high-quality army, air force, and navy that acts as a force for stability and order in the continent and especially in southern Africa. Whatever woes betide the land, we can rest assured that a well-equipped navy is guarding the southern seas.

Dear Mr. Kearns,

I would be honored for Mr. Gregory to include my piece on the SA Fleet Review on his site. Even just a quick gander shows it is both thorough and wide-ranging. And the Edinburgh procession ("John Burns, Arctic Convoy Veteran, Edinburgh, last journey down royal mile") was especially interesting.

Thanks very much!

Very best,


Dear Andrew,

My grateful thanks for your generousity in allowing us to replicate your piece about the South African Naval Review on AHOY. It gives an added flavour to a Naval site, and not too much is available from the SA arena that is worth using.
I have fond memories of both South Africa, Edinburgh, and Zimbabwe. I first visited the former as an 18 year old Midshipman in HMAS Australia way back in 1940. See this URL: about an unusual Great Dane named Nuisance.

I spent some three weeks in Edinburgh in 1947, doing a mine sweeping course on the Firth of Forth, as part of a Specialist 
Torpedo Anti Submarine course in Royal Navy schools. Denise and I have been in Edinburgh a few years ago, lovely city.

On a sunset cruise on the Zambezi River in 1994, I met Denise, she was with a girl friend, had been widowed some 8 years, I was on my own, and my wife of over 40 years had died of cancer some years earlier. We married in 1999.

I enjoyed a good look at your web site Andrew, it ranges over a wide spectrum of interesting subjects, congratulations!

Again thank you for allowing us to use your work.

With best wishes.


This site was created as a resource for educational use and the promotion of historical awareness. All rights of publicity of the individuals named herein are expressly reserved, and, should be respected consistent with the reverence in which this memorial site was established.

Copyright© 1984/2014 Mackenzie J. Gregory All rights reserved